Free · printable · updated 2026-10-20
The Agent Income Evidence Checklist
How to tell whether an AI-agent income claim is real, in ten questions. It takes about five minutes per claim. It will not tell you whether you can earn the same amount; nothing honest can.
-
Is there a number, a period, and a unit?
"$12,400 in September, revenue" can be checked. "Six figures with agents" cannot. Revenue, profit, and payouts are different things; note which one is claimed.
-
Who is the source, and did they see the money themselves?
The person who earned it, a payer, a filing, or a payment dashboard is firsthand. A repost, a thread summary, or a newsletter quoting someone else is secondary. Trace a secondary claim back to its original before you weigh it.
-
Is there anything outside the claimant's own words?
Public filings, a marketplace profile with visible reviews, a named customer, a public payout page, or a revenue screen with a date. A screenshot alone is weak: it is easy to crop, reuse, or fake.
-
Is a real customer paying for a real use case?
Look for a named or describable buyer and what they get. A service that only sells "how to make money with agents" to other aspiring earners is a course funnel, not evidence the method works.
-
What does the agent actually do, and what does a person still do?
Separate the work: finding customers, doing the task, checking output, handling payment and support. Most "autonomous" claims still have a person selling, reviewing, or fixing. That can be a fine business; it is just not hands-off income.
-
Is the workflow shown, or only described?
A demo, a repository, a run log, or a step-by-step build that someone else could repeat counts for more than a description. Ask what would break if the person stopped watching it for a week.
-
Are the costs stated?
Model and tool subscriptions, API usage, ads, contractors, and the person's own hours. A revenue figure without costs says nothing about profit.
-
Is it an employer's posted pay or a contest prize?
Posted salaries, hourly rates, and prizes are what a payer offers for human work. They are not earnings an agent produced, and not proof that anyone received that amount.
-
Does the claimant profit from you believing it?
A course, community, affiliate link, or "done-for-you system" attached to the claim is a conflict of interest. It does not make the claim false; it means you need outside evidence before trusting it.
-
Which red flags are present?
Guaranteed or passive income, a countdown or limited spots, pressure to pay before you see details, income shown only as a lifestyle, no named business, or a refund policy you cannot find.
Reading your answers
| What you found | What it means |
|---|---|
| Mostly yes on 2, 3, 4 and 7, with an outside record | Strong. Still not a promise you will match it. |
| A firsthand claim with some detail but no outside record | Credible self-report. Worth watching, not banking on. |
| Only the claimant's word, no costs, no customer | Self-reported only. Treat the number as unknown. |
| Red flags from item 10, or the evidence is selling you something | Unverified. Likely marketing. |
This is the same reasoning behind the A to D grades in the directory. See the methodology for how we apply it, and our own numbers on building in public.
To save a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF". Free to share with a link back to this page.